PORT CHARLOTTE — Melissa Aniskewicz has 10 chickens in her backyard: Rosie, Heather, Trixie, Dixie, Minnie, Cookie, Ellie, Betty, Helga and Crystal.
The hens live in a 300-square-foot enclosure, with built-in nests to lay their multi-colored eggs, along with room to walk and jump, lit by solar string lights in their half-acre Port Charlotte lot.
Do you think Charlotte County should change its ordinance on backyard chickens
“They’re spoiled,” Aniskewicz said.
Aniskewicz and her boyfriend, Rob Horton, spent weeks building the coop for the first six chickens they bought.
“It gets the kids outside,” Horton said, “I thought it’d be a good family activity.”
Horton, Aniskewicz and her two kids, Emilee, 9, and Elyssa Drayer, 10, eat fresh eggs, some blue and others brown, almost every morning, usually scrambled. They even give excess eggs to their neighbors.
When everyone gets home, the family occasionally lets their 10 chickens wander their fenced-in yard. By dusk, the chickens strut back in their enclosure, ready to go to bed.
However, Aniskewicz received a letter from Charlotte County’s Code Compliance Division July 31 saying having chickens is a “prohibited use of the property,” and therefore violating one of the county’s codes. The county requested she remove her chickens from the property within 10 days of receiving the letter.
Residential single-family lots are allowed to have pets, and Charlotte County Animal Control’s definition of domestic animals includes goats, sheep, dogs and poultry. Only breeding, boarding, and training is prohibited.
“There was nothing saying you couldn’t have (chickens),” Aniskewicz said.
However, the county contends chickens fall under livestock, which is allowed only in agricultural districts.
“Calling an animal a pet doesn’t change whether it is permitted on (residential single-family) zoned property,” said Charlotte County spokesperson Brian Gleason.
Aniskewicz created Charlotte CLUCK, or Citizens Lobbying for Urban Chicken Keeping, to fight for code changes so residents can keep their beloved pet chickens in their homes, in their backyards, with fresh eggs to eat in the morning.
Chickens are welcome in Sarasota County
Aniskewicz is modeling her movement after Sarasota CLUCK, which successfully convinced commissioners to pass the ordinance with a four-to-one vote Oct. 10, 2016. However, this victory took years to cultivate.
Jono Miller, the founder of Sarasota CLUCK, created the group in 2009 while having 25 chickens in his backyard illegally.
“I knew chickens weren’t a neighborhood killer,” Miller said, having raised chickens as a kid. He received tremendous support, with roughly 47 people showing up to his first official CLUCK meeting, he said.
The group set their sights on the city of Sarasota, working with staff until, eventually, the city commission amended their ordinances February 2011 to allow backyard chickens in residential areas. After a three year probationary period, the city of Sarasota voted unanimously Feb. 18, 2014 to permanently allow chickens.
The next step was tackling Sarasota County. The county commission started exploring allowing backyard chickens May 10, 2016, basing their ordinance after the City of Sarasota.
Five months later, the ordinance was adopted, allowing residents to keep as many as four hens in their backyards with a movable coop.
“The idea is that if a coop can be moved, if one neighbor has a lot of heartache, you can move it to the other part,” Miller said. Plus, this type of coop makes it easier, and more comfortable, to move the hens during a hurricane.
Three years later, on average, the county receives less than 10 chicken-related complaints each year, according to Sarasota County spokesperson Brianne Grant.
Not just winging it
In 2014, a conditional section was added to Charlotte County code, allowing chickens in residential zones if used for 4H, Future Farmers of America and similar organizations. This requires official documentation and only three chickens, no roosters, in a pen at least 10 feet from property lines.
Since her violation, Aniskewicz signed up two kids in her home. They attended their first meeting Sept. 11, where the group’s leader said they have more people this year than they have had in a very long time.
“I do know many people have joined (4H) for the security of being able to keep their chickens,” Aniskewicz said.
There are a few routes residents can take to amend the county’s zoning code, according to the county’s code.
Many of these are through the Charlotte County Board of County Commissioners. Citizens can speak to the board on any topic during citizen’s input, prompting a discussion to be added to the agenda. This is how Sarasota CLUCK did it.
Citizen’s input takes place at 1 p.m. on the second board meeting of the month, according to Gleason. Citizens can also email board members at assistant@CharlotteCountyFL.gov or call 941-743-1300.
However, Gleason is doubtful any route involving the board will yield the amendment Aniskewicz wants.
“It’s not really something that’s going to change,” Gleason said, with the issue having been raised multiple times throughout the years. “The board’s position has been they’re not going to change this ordinance.”
Aniskewicz hopes this time the board will change its mind.
“Even our neighboring counties have amended their residential ordinance to allow chickens,” she said. “Times have changed.”
If the commissioners do not adopt the ordinance, citizens can go around the board by going through a formal petition process. The petition must be submitted and approved by the supervisor of elections, then the petitioner has six months to obtain signatures from at least 10% of eligible voters.
The board will then hold a public hearing on the proposed ordinance and vote. If it is not adopted, the issue will be placed on the general election ballot to be voted on, according to Charlotte County statute.
The county has had 10 chicken code cases since 2016, according to Gleason.
With 141,598 active registered voters as of Aug. 27, this would mean CLUCK needs at least 14,000 signatures.
Charlotte CLUCK currently has an online petition with 1,160 signatures as of Tuesday.
The online petition, though, “has no legal standing,” Gleason said.
“Charlotte CLUCK is the voice for all chicken owners, chicken lovers, and chickens of Charlotte County,” Aniskewicz said.
Aniskewicz ideally wants an ordinance allowing up to five hens on a lot in residential zones, with the coop containing at least four square feet per fowl. The ordinance would prohibit roosters, the slaughtering of chickens or the sale of eggs.
“(Chickens are) very easy to take care of,” Aniskewicz said, teaching some to jump on command. “Any age can handle them ... they’re low maintenance and can’t hurt you.”